Kaitlin's Top 10 (2019)

1. Race For The Galaxy
2. Flash Point Fire Rescue
3. T.I.M.E. Stories
4. Agricola
5. Dominion
6. SmallWorld
7. Cryptid
8. PowerGrid
9. Ascension
10. Dixit
11. Splendor

Margot's Top 40+ for 2017

1. Pandemic Legacy Season 1
2. Flash Point Fire Rescue
3. Ascension
4. Dominion
5. Automobiles
6. Splendor
7. Legends of Andor
8. Five Tribes
9. Viticulture
10. Celestia
11. Ticket to Ride
12. Castles of Burgundy
13. Istanbul
14. Jaipur
15. Smallworld
16. Alhambra
17. Puerto Rico
18. Tikal
19. Princes of Florence
20. Patchwork
21. Ra
22. Marrying Mr Darcy
23. Gloomhaven
24. Downfall  of Pompeii
25. Codenames
26. T.I.M.E. Stories
27. Dixit
28. PowerGrid
29. Bohnanza
30. Takenoko
31. Ghost Stories
32. Cosmic Run Rapid Fire
33. Snow Tails
34. Grand Austria Hotel
35. Tzolkin
36. Timeline
37. Caverna
38. Hollywood Blockbuster
39. Incan Gold
40. Zooloretto
41. Sushi Go!
42. Super Motherload
43. Stockpile

Kaitlin's 2017 Top 20

1. Race for the Galaxy
2. Agricola
3. Small World
4. Dixit
5. Time Stories
6. Flash Point Fire Rescue
7. Caylus
8. Dominion
9. Pandemic
10. Powergrid
11. King of New York
12. Scythe
13. San Juan
14. Bohnanza
15. Ticket to Ride
16. Sushi Go
17. Agricola All Creatures Big and Small (2 player)
18. Mystery of the Abbey
19. Bang!
20. Stockpile

New from last year in bold

Kaitlin's Top 20 All-Time (2016)

(1) Race for the Galaxy
(2) Agricola
(3) Dixit
(4) Dominion
(5) Power Grid
(6) Small World
(7) Flash Point Fire Rescue
(8) Caylus
(9) King of New York
(10) Bang!
(11) Mystery of the Abbey
(12) Pandemic
(13) Sushi Go!
(14) Ascension
(15) Agricola: All Creatures Big and Small
(16) Bohnanza
(17) Battle Sheep
(18) Gangster
(19) Downfall of Pompeii
(20) Battle Lore

Margot's Top 40 for 2016

Games appearing for the first time because they were recently purchased bold

(1) Dominion
(2) Splendor
(3) Five Tribes
(4) Ascension
(5) Flash Point Fire Rescue
(6) Pandemic
(7) Castles of Burgundy
(8) Bohnanza
(9) Forbidden Desert
(10) Puerto Rico
(11) Istanbul
(12) Viticulture
(13) Automobiles
(14) Alhambra
(15) Small World
(16) Ticket to Ride
(17) Patchwork
(18) Among the Stars
(19) Jaipur
(20) Takenoko
(21) Favour of the Pharaoh
(22) The Grizzled
(23) Codenames
(24) Princes of Florence
(25) Powergrid
(26) Tikal
(27) Ghost Stories
(28) Marrying Mr Darcy
(29) Ra
(30) Sushi Go!
(31) Tokaido
(32) Downfall of Pompeii
(33) Lord of the Rings Co-op
(34) Lord of the Rings LCG
(35) Tsuro
(36) Karuba
(37) Tzolkin
(38) Caverna
(39) Blue Moon
(40) Voyages of Marco Polo
(41) Star Realms
(42) King of New York
(43) Orleans
(44) Quadropolis
(45) Zooloretto
(46) Lewis and Clark
(47) Concordia
(48) Incan Gold
(49) Relic Runners
(50) Hollywood Blockbuster
(51) Gold West
(52) Snow Tails
(53) New York 1901
(54) Timeline
(55) Tides of Time
(56) Dixit
(57) Wits and Wagers
(58) No Thanks!
(59) Buy Word
(60) San Juan
(61) Carcasonne
(62) Game of 49
(63) Red 7

Margot's Top 20 for 2015

Here are Margot's top 20 (or so) games at this point in time (Sept 2015)

1. Dominion
2. Ascension
3. Jaipur
4. Star Realms
5. Splendor
6. Castles of Burgundy
7. Sushi Go
8. King of New York
9. Ticket To Ride
10. Bohnanza
11. Alhambra
12. Five Tribes
13. Smallworld
14. Puerto Rico
15. Forbidden Desert
16. Powergrid
17. Viticulture
18. Pandemic
19. Zooloretto
20. Lewis and Clark
21. Princes of Florence
22. Pompeii
23. Timeline
24. Ghost Stories
25. Lord of the Rings LCG
26. Carcasonne
27. Nations the Dice Game
28. Relic Runners
29. Ra
30. Tsuro
31. Incan Gold
32. Hollywood Blockbuster
33. Blue Moon
34. Game of 49
35. Tzolkin
36. Dutch Blitz
37. Dixit

Margot's Top 20 Games

After seeing someone else's top 100 games, Margot wondered why they had Puerto Rico so low on the list (in the 80s).   After some work, she came up with the following top 20.

(20) Tzolkin
(19) Carcasonne
(18) Lord Of The Rings LCG
(17) Ghost Stories
(16) Sushi Go!
(15) Dutch Blitz
(14) Downfall of Pompeii
(13) Hollywood Blockbuster
(12) Princes of Florence
(11) RA
(10) Castles of Burgundy
(9) Pandemic
(8) Forbidden Desert
(7) Ticket To Ride
(6) Puerto Rico
(5) Alhambra
(4) Powergrid
(3) Small world
(2) Bohnanza
(1) Dominion